Northern Premier League - Midlands Division
| Season | Club |
|---|---|
| Total | - |
Southern League Premier Division Central
| Season | Club |
|---|---|
| Total | - |
Diamonds Total (League & Cup)
| Season |
|---|
| Total |
Result
 
(29 (re-arranged))
0 - 3Northern Premier League - Midlands Division
2024/25
Hayden Road Sports Ground AFC Rushden & Diamonds v QuornAttendance: 266 Man of the Match: David Adegbola Captain: Calvin Green
|
(31)
3 - 0Southern League Premier Division Central
2022/23
Mander Cruickshank Solicitors Stadium Coalville Town v AFC Rushden & DiamondsAttendance: 609 Captain: Dean Snedker
|
|
(10)
0 - 7Southern League Premier Division Central
2022/23
Hayden Road AFC Rushden & Diamonds v Coalville TownAttendance: 374 Captain: Nathan Hicks
|
|
(37)
2 - 2Southern League Premier Division Central
2021/22
Owen Street Sports Ground Coalville Town v AFC Rushden & DiamondsAttendance: 491 Man of the Match: Jordan Graham Captain: Fernando Bell-Toxtle
|
|
(First Round Qualifying)
5 - 2FA Cup
2021/22
Mander Cruickshank Solicitors Stadium Coalville Town v AFC Rushden & DiamondsAttendance: 384 Man of the Match: Jay Williams Captain: Liam Dolman
|
|
(2)
2 - 1Southern League Premier Division Central
2021/22
Hayden Road AFC Rushden & Diamonds v Coalville TownAttendance: 387 Man of the Match: Ben Garwood (as chosen by Radio Diamonds) Captain: Liam Dolman
|
